FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Thesis, dissertations, books

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 9 |

«The Crusades from the Perspective of Byzantium and the Muslim World edited by Angeliki E. Laiou and Roy Parviz Mottahedeh published by Dumbarton Oaks ...»

-- [ Page 2 ] --

A. Provisioning Major challenges were posed by the large size of the crusading armies. According to the most recent estimates, the Peasant Crusade had around 20,000 participants; the main armies at Nicaea counted approximately 50,000 to 60,000 members including noncombatants. Many had already died on the way to Constantinople. The Crusade of 1101, for which there are huge contemporary estimates, must have been larger.17 No figures are J. France, Victory in the East: A Military History of the First Crusade (Cambridge–New York, 1994), 142, and ` ´ J. Flori, “Un probleme de methodologie: La valeur des nombres chez les chroniqueurs du Moyen Age: A pro´´ ` ` pos des effectifs de la premiere Croisade,” Moyen Age 99 (1995): 399–422. J. Heers, Liberer Jerusalem: La premiere Croisade (1095–1107) (Paris, 1995), does not give estimates. On the Crusade of 1100–1101, see J. L. Cate, “The Crusade of 1101,” in K. M. Setton, ed., History of the Crusades, vol. 1, The First Hundred Years, ed. M. W. Baldwin (Madison, Wisc., 1969), 343–67.

Cate, “The Crusade of 1101,” 351.

[ 162 ] Byzantine Trade given for the French and German armies of the Second Crusade, but combined they must have been as large as those of the First Crusade. For the army of Frederick I Barbarossa, we have the figure of 100,000, which includes 20,000 mounted troops.18 In terms of the problems of provisioning, we might compare these figures with the most recent and persuasive estimates of the size of the Komnenian army on campaign, which is approximately 15,000 to 20,000 men, thus much smaller than the Crusaders’ armies.19 One must also take into account the length of time the Crusaders spent on Byzantine soil;

thinking only of the Balkans, I have estimated an average of two to two and a half months for most of the armies of the First Crusade, except for those of Raymond of Toulouse and Bohemond, which took five and a half to six months. The passage of most of the armies, including the Peasant Crusade, was swift: the comparison to locusts, found in both Anna Komnene and Orderic Vitalis,20 seems apposite. The armies of the Second Crusade took two and a half to three months. But that of Frederick Barbarossa spent almost nine months on Byzantine soil, mostly in southern Bulgaria and Thrace, heavily taxing the resources of the area. As these numbers suggest, the problems of provisioning were ubiquitous; as for questions of exchange, those arose on the ground, and, during the Second and Third Crusades, formed a part of the negotiations for safe passage.

As is well known, the First Crusade was too amorphous and disorganized for formal arrangements to have been made beforehand to assure provisioning, although by 1101 agreements were indeed concluded as the Lombard army was about to enter Bulgaria.21 Provisions do not seem to have been brought as far as the Byzantine Empire, although one of the chroniclers mentions that the Crusaders carried some provisions with them;22 these undoubtedly were exhausted before the Crusaders left Western Europe. The Crusaders also brought money and marks of silver with them, presumably to be used to buy provisions.23 The problem of provisioning was recurrent during the passage of the armies of the First Crusade and of the subsequent two. The army of Raymond of St. Gilles, passing through Dalmatia, could get neither safe-conduct nor commercium until it reached Skoutari, where, in January 1097, Raymond made a pact with the local ruler (Vodin), giving him much money so that the army would be allowed to buy provisions, although Vodin’s promises seem to have remained a dead letter.24 The Crusaders were certainly expected, by the Byzantine authorities, to buy their food: Alexios I, as soon as he heard of the Crusade, had sent generals to Durazzo and Avlona to ensure that there would be panegyreis (the Latin term is usually mercatum or necessarium negotium)25 in all the lands along the France, Victory in the East, 136.

´ ` J.-C. Cheynet, “Les effectifs de l’armee byzantine aux Xe–XIe siecle,” CahCM 38 (1995): 319–35, at 331–32.

Alexiade 10.5.7, ed. B. Leib (with P. Gautier), 4 vols. (Paris, 1939–76), 2:208; Orderic Vitalis, The Ecclesiastical History, ed. and trans. M. Chibnall, 6 vols. (Oxford, 1969–80), 5.30.

Albert of Aix, Historia Hierosolymitana, RHC, HOcc 4 (Paris, 1879), 559; Orderic Vitalis, 5:327.

Roberti Monachi Historia Iherosolimitana, RHC, HOcc 3 (Paris, 1866), 744, on Bohemond.

See below, 168–69.

J. Hugh and L. Hill, eds., Le “Liber” de Raymond d’Aguilers (Paris, 1969), 37–38; Guillaume de Tyr, Chronique, ed. R. Huygens, CC continuatio mediaevalis 63–63 (Turnhout, 1986), 2.17 (1:182 ff ).

E.g., Orderic Vitalis, 5:31, 33, 43, 49, 69.

Angeliki E. Laiou [ 163 ] way.26 Some Crusaders, especially the excitable Tancred,27 thought it too bad that they should have to buy food—and they took different courses of action.28 The emperor, perhaps in response, seems to have made the availability of provisions contingent on the Crusaders’ oath of fealty or friendship, as also happened during the Second and Third Crusades.29 The Byzantine authorities seem to have been confident that they could provide adequate markets, so much so that Niketas Choniates thought that Manuel Komnenos’ failure to supply adequate markets to the participants of the Second Crusade was deliberate.

Byzantine armies on campaign normally brought some of their provisions with them, or bought them along the way, as long as they were on friendly territory.30 But the Crusader armies, especially those of the Second and Third Crusades, which crossed into the Balkans all together, were much larger than a Byzantine army on campaign. In fact, the passage of the crusading armies taxed the productive resources of the area and most particularly the mechanisms of distribution. It is surprising that the system did not significantly break down before the time of Frederick Barbarossa.

The provisioning of the armies of the First Crusade (including that of 1101) on Byzantine territory was carried out in three ways. First, the Crusaders bought food, and a recurrent complaint is that there was no food to be bought or, as in Kastoria, that the inhabitants did not wish to sell, being suspicious of the Crusaders’ motives.31 In the Balkans, in Asia Minor, and also in the Holy Land, much of the provisioning of the crusading army depended on the purchase of food (and fodder for the horses), as William of Tyre makes most clearly evident. Indeed, the fact that various crusading chronicles quote prices, mostly at times of famine, proves that food was bought.32 The second way they found food was from imperial donations—either at times of joint victory or at times of considerable hardship. Alexios I perhaps fed some of the army of Peter the Hermit in Constantinople and promised Hugh of Vermandois not only an adequate market (copiosum mercatum) but also alms for the poor.33 Before the capture of Nicaea, Alexiade 10.5.9 (ed. Leib, 2:209). According to Anna, when Alexios heard of the crusade, he told his ´ `` ` ´ officials to panhgurei" te dayilei'" ejx aJpasw'n tw'n cwrw'n kata thn oJdon ejxagein. Later, Alexios heard ´ ˆ ` ´ about the arrival of more Crusaders, and again he sent word to ta zwarkh' toutoi" ejrcomenoi" ejpicorhgein ejp∆ aujtv' toutv tetagmenoi", wJ" mh labei'n aujtou" to parapan ejschkenai. Alexiade 10.10.3 (ed. Leib, ´ `` ´ ` ´ ´ 2:228). Orderic Vitalis says that during the passage of the crusaders of Walter Sans-Avoir, the doux and the officials of Philippopolis allowed them to enter the city “et mercatum concesserunt,” which they had not done before: Ecclesiastical History, 5.31 (this information is found nowhere else, according to the editor’s note).

R. Hill, ed., Gesta Francorum et aliorum Hierosolimitanorum (London, 1962), 10.

See below, 164.

E.g., Robert the Monk, 744, 748, 749. Also William of Tyre, 2.6, 2.12, 2.14 (1:168–69, 175–77, 178–79).

´ R. Vari, Leonis imperatoris Tactica, 2 vols. (Budapest, 1917–22), 1:225.

Robert the Monk, 745: Bohemond tries to get “forum rerum venalium”; cf. Hill, Gesta Francorum 8:

“quesivimus mercatum.” Cf. Orderic Vitalis, 5.45, 49.

` ` ´ ` ` Among the prices, see Alexiade 11.4.3 (ed. Leib, 3:20): in Antioch, hJ kefalh tou' boo" ejpi trisi crusinoi" stath'rsi ajpempolei'to. On the fact that food was normally purchased as opposed to donated or acquired by raids, see William of Tyre, 1:142, 143, 148, 164–65, 173, 176, 178, 184.

“[I]mperator iusserat dari mercatum, sicuti erat in civitate”: Hill, Gesta Francorum 2; but he uses mercatum also to mean a market; cf. Robert the Monk, 732: “mercatum eis habere concedebat, quod etiam in civitate erat.” Orderic Vitalis, 5.43; cf. p. 327 on ingentia dona to the leaders of the Crusade of 1101 and p. 335 on shipByzantine Trade Alexios allowed a ship to bring provisions for purchase; but after the fall of that city, he gave to the poor of the army alms, which Stephen of Blois defines as distributions of food.34 The third way in which the Crusaders found food was plunder. Relatively limited during the First Crusade, at least on Byzantine territory, despite the depredations of Tancred and Bohemond and those of the Lombard participants in the Crusade of 1101,35 it became a way of life when the Crusaders entered Turkish territory. Spoils of war, not quite plunder, were also available, as also were large donations by the rulers of various Muslim towns once the Crusaders had entered Syria and Palestine.

As for the Second and Third Crusades, the matter of provisioning was paramount in the eyes of the Crusader leaders, and in the eyes of the Byzantine emperors it had become, along with safe conduct, the most powerful negotiating tool. In his letter to the pope regarding the crusade of Louis VII, Manuel I Komnenos promised safe passage and markets (and suitable exchange: “forum idoneum, concambium competens”), in exchange for an oath of security for his realm.36 He then sent orders everywhere to have provisions brought to the roads through which the Crusaders would pass.37 The German ´ ` ` ` army too was promised “hospitality” (uJpodoch'" te ajpolauonta" eij" to eijko" kai ´ filofrosunh" th'" allh") in exchange for an oath of friendship.38 The governor of “ ˆ“ Nish, Michael Branas, was ordered to provide “necessities” (proujnoeito hdh tw'n ajnagkaiwn aujtoi", outw prostetagmenon aujtv'), and similarly in Sofia. In Sofia, at least, ´ ˆ ´ 39 ” it is certain that its governor made sure that Louis VII had the right to buy provisions.40 Manuel forced the French to reconfirm their oaths in exchange for market privileges several times: most importantly in Constantinople, where he exacted the oath of homage in return for a promise of guides, fair exchange, and markets everywhere,41 and, later, in Attaleia.42 When arrangements broke down, either by design on the part of the Byzantines or by chance, or because there was not enough food to feed the Crusaders (as in Attaleia), the Crusaders plundered.43 The arrangements with Frederick Barbarossa, as reported by Niketas Choniates, Ansbert and other sources, were almost a point-by-point copy of those made earlier with Conrad and Louis VII—which means that the imperial bureaucracy had learned more

–  –  –

or less what to do, unless it simply means that Choniates is repeating himself. The second eventuality, however, is unlikely, since he had firsthand knowledge of the later arrangements, and the statements of Odo of Deuil (and Ansbert) and Choniates corroborate each other at several points.44 Once again the quid pro quo was safety for imperial lands in return for markets, although, as is well known, the problem deteriorated into a conflict over imperial titles. Once again the emperor appealed to the provincial governors to “transfer goods from the various regions to where the king would pass.”45 In the case of the Third Crusade, promises of safe-conduct and optimi fori were made in Nuremberg in November 1186, and repeated in Nish and Branitsevo. The question of iustum concambium arose in October 1189.46 But arrangements broke down very soon indeed, and the German army—100,000 of them—found its food by plunder, which must have been very painful for the population. Permission to plunder was solemnized by the Treaty of Adrianople in February 1190. According to Choniates, at the time of the Third Crusade, the Turks of Konya also promised safe-passage and provisions, but broke their promises.47 How was this food marketed, and who sold it? In all cases, the emperors gave the original orders, which mandated two courses of action: that markets should be provided to the armies and that provisions should be collected by the governors of the regions.48 William of Tyre, perhaps not entirely trustworthy on this point, adds that Alexios’ edict regarding the army of Bohemond envisaged the death penalty for anyone who disregarded his orders to “iusto precio et equo pondere ducis exercitui quelibet mercimonia venderentur.” His narrative often reiterates that Alexios not only gave the Crusaders the right to buy and sell, but also ordered that the sale be carried out with correct weights and measures and at a just price.49 During the Crusade of 1100–1101, permission was given the Crusaders to buy and sell (“emendi et vendendi”) in Rosa (the Rusa of the First Crusade: Xanthe or Komotini), Panidos, Rodosto, Didymoteichon, “castello...

de Natura,” Selymbria, Adrianople, Philippopolis;50 some of these towns, like Panidos and Rodosto, were major grain markets.

Pages:     | 1 || 3 | 4 |   ...   | 9 |

Similar works:

«® WD TV Live Hub ™ Media Center Benutzerhandbuch Inhaltsverzeichnis 1 Wichtige Informationen für den Benutzer......... 1 Wichtige Sicherheitsanweisungen.......................... 1 WD®-Serviceleistungen und Support........................ 2 Aufzeichnen Ihrer WD-Produktinformationen.................. 3 Registrieren Ihres WD-Produkts............................ 4 Zubehör............»

«Text Compression for Dynamic Document Databases∗ Alistair Moffat† Justin Zobel‡ Neil Sharman§ March 1994 Abstract For compression of text databases, semi-static word-based methods provide good performance in terms of both speed and disk space, but two problems arise. First, the memory requirements for the compression model during decoding can be unacceptably high. Second, the need to handle document insertions means that the collection must be periodically recompressed, if compression...»

«ASYMPTOTIC DENSITY, COMPUTABLE TRACEABILITY, AND 1-RANDOMNESS URI ANDREWS, MINGZHONG CAI, DAVID DIAMONDSTONE, CARL JOCKUSCH, AND STEFFEN LEMPP Abstract. Let r be a real number in the unit interval [0, 1]. A set A ⊆ ω is said to be coarsely computable at density r if there is a computable function f such that {n | f (n) = A(n)} has lower density at least r. Our main results are that A is coarsely computable at density 1/2 if A is either computably traceable or truth-table reducible to a...»

«dr löwe dr löwe Startseite Dr. Loewen Coaching Liebe Besucher, vielen Dank, dass Sie meine Internetseite besuchen. Mein Ziel ist, Menschen und Organisationen zum Erfolg zu verhelfen. Seit mehr als Loewe. Individuelle Home Entertainment Systeme. Neben den neuen Features bietet die Loewe DR+ Feature Disk auch 1 TB Speicherkapazität und Sie können Ihr Loewe TV Gerät oder ihr bestehendes DR+ Produkte Loewe. Individuelle Home Entertainment Systeme. 7 Mein Loewe; 8 Händlersuche; 9 Unternehmen;...»

«www.itcon.org Journal of Information Technology in Construction ISSN 1874-4753 INTEGRATION OF BIM AND GENERATIVE DESIGN TO EXPLOIT AEC CONCEPTUAL DESIGN INNOVATION SUBMITTED: August 2013 REVISED: December 2013 PUBLISHED: September 2014 at http://www.itcon.org/2014/21 GUEST EDITORS: Wang X., Li H., Wong J. and Li H. Sepehr Abrishami, PhD Student, Centre for Sustainable Development, The Grenfell-Baines School of Architecture, Construction and Environment, University of Central Lancashire,...»

«April 25, 2013 Portugal. The Man Team With Danger Mouse on Experimental 'Evil Friends' Portland-based band embraces pop charm on new album Last spring, two weeks and 10 songs into the recording process for their new album Evil Friends, Portugal. The Man scrapped nearly everything they'd accomplished. We were super excited about it, bassist Zach Carothers tells Rolling Stone of ditching all but two songs they'd recorded at Sonic Ranch Studios in El Paso, Texas. Instead, they started from scratch...»

«The NeuViz Data Visualization Tool for Visualizing Internet-Measurements Data! ! ! ! G. Futia, E. Zimuel, S. Basso, J.C. De Martin ! ! ! ! ! Abstract. In this paper we present NeuViz, a data processing and visualization architecture for network measurement experiments. NeuViz has been tailored to work on the data produced by Neubot (Net Neutrality Bot), an Internet bot that performs periodic, active network performance tests. We show that NeuViz is an effective tool to navigate Neubot data to...»

«Mature Worker Pre-Employment Training Toolbox Workbook Creation Date: March 2010 Inside this Workbook: Module 1: Finding Your New Voice—Introduction 6 Module 2: Finding Your New Voice—Transferable Skills 35 Module 3: Technology Today 54 Module 4: Job Search Tools & Strategies 71 Module 5: Interviewing & Job Placement Essentials 96 Module 6: Workplace Culture 119 Module 7: Community Resources (Optional) Module 8: Alternative Employment (Optional) Appendix: Resume Writing & Interviewing...»

«Alumni Admission Network Alumni Interview Program Contents Program Contact Information 2 Alumni Interview Program Overview 3 Volunteer Expectations of Service 4 Interviewing Guidelines 5 Completing the Interview Evaluation Form 7 Program Contact Information | To Learn More or To Volunteer www.alumni.emory.edu/interviewing Visit Call 866.727.6485 Emory Staff Contacts Jamie Chan 06C Sasha Thompson 11C Assistant Dean of Admission Admission Counselor Emory College of Arts and Sciences Emory College...»

«Original Gebrauchsanleitung 3in1 Funkauslöser-Set Gewerbering 26 86666 Burgheim Tel. +49 84 32 / 9489-0 Fax. +49 84 32 / 9489 8333 eMail: info@foto-walser.de www.foto-walser.de Inhalt 1. So verstehen Sie diese Gebrauchsanleitung richtig 1.1 Kennzeichnungen am Gerät 1.2 Kennzeichnungen in dieser Gebrauchsanleitung 2. Wichtige Sicherheitsinformation 3. Gerät auspacken und prüfen 4. Kompatibilitätsliste 5. Übersicht über Bestandteile und Bedienelemente der Geräte. 7 6. Kurzanleitung 7....»

«February 2003 ECN-C03-016 Carbon dioxide sequestration by mineral carbonation Literature Review W.J.J. Huijgen & R.N.J. Comans Revisions A B Made by: Approved: ECN-Clean Fossil Fuels Environmental Risk Assessment W.J.J. Huijgen R.N.J. Comans Checked by: Issued: H.T.J. Reijers J.W. Erisman Preface This literature review is part of a PhD-programme ‘CO2 sequestration in alkaline solid wastes’. This programme began in January 2002 and will finish in December 2005. The research is performed...»

«Adventure #12 Last Session. T he heroes confronted the spectator, a one-eyed guardian of the Forge of Spells, and after a fairly amiable and non-violent confrontation, they convinced him that his long assignment had been completed and that he (she? it?) was free to return home. That segued immediately into a pro-violent confrontation with Mormesk the Wraith, another occupant of the mine who was determined to control any and all “treasures” in the area. They whipped his butt pretty past, but...»

<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dis.xlibx.info - Thesis, dissertations, books

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.