WWW.DIS.XLIBX.INFO
FREE ELECTRONIC LIBRARY - Thesis, dissertations, books
 
<< HOME
CONTACTS



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 ||

«DIVORCE AND THE WELFARE OF THE CHILD IN JAPAN Matthew J. McCauley† Abstract: Current Japanese legal institutions are ill-equipped to resolve the ...»

-- [ Page 4 ] --

Problematic enforcement mechanisms must be reformed to make parenting plans effective. Even if parenting plans were to become mandatory in Japan, it would do little good if they were not accompanied by a stronger enforcement mechanism. This needs to have a dispute resolution mechanism built into the document itself and have the backing of legal institutions that are willing to hold both parties to their agreement.101 These institutions need to be able to serve as an impartial third party mediator that will work with the parents to resolve disputes and issues of noncompliance as well as provide a stronger legal remedy in case this mediation fails.102 While there have been no thorough studies in the area, mediators have proven to be effective at defusing high-tension situations. 103 Requiring judicial affirmation and parenting plans, and actively enforcing agreements DOUGLAS, supra note 92, at 68.

E.g., OR. REV. STAT. § 107.102 (1997).

DIANE N. LYE, WASH. STATE GENDER AND JUSTICE COMM’N AND DOMESTIC RELATIONS COMM’N,

WHAT THE RECORDS SHOW: AN ANALYSIS OF RECENT PARENTING PLANS IN WASHINGTON STATE, (1999)

(this is the most recent study on point); Jane W. Ellis, Plans, Protections, and Professional Intervention:

Innovations in Divorce Custody Reform and the Role of Legal Professionals, 24 U. MICH. J.L. REFORM 65 (1990).

Ellis, supra note 98.

LYE, supra note 98, at v-vi, 3-42.

DOUGLAS, supra note 92, at 75-77.

Id.

Id.

604 PACIFIC RIM LAW & POLICY JOURNAL VOL. 20 NO. 3 would go a long way toward making kyōgi rikon more equitable for everyone, especially young children.

C. Future Reforms Need to Address All Three Areas of Custody, Visitation, and Kyōgi Rikon With the help of citizen groups and private activists, the movement for joint custody and visitation rights has finally started to gain traction among Japanese policymakers.104 On January 29, 2010, Takao Tanase, a lawyer and law professor who is actively advocating for legal reform of Japanese visitation and custody laws, brought a proposal before the Japanese House of Representatives for special legislation that would create a firm right to visitation, establish a joint custody system, and require divorcing parents to create a parenting plan.105 Following Mr. Tanase’s proposal, the Committee on Judicial Affairs has debated issues of custody and visitation on several occasions. 106 Speakers at these hearings raised many concerns about the current system, looking at the issue both domestically and internationally.107 While there was a relative consensus that visitation laws were ripe for reform, Justice Minister Chiba shared some significant reservations toward adopting a joint custody system.108 Her concerns were largely based on the argument that sole custody was better for the welfare of the child because it helped provide stability, and that most of the issues surrounding parental alienation can be solved through stronger visitation rights. 109 While the simple solution proposed by Minister Chiba may sound appealing, reform of the visitation system is not enough. All three relevant areas of the law, visitation, custody, and kyōgi rikon need to change to adequately protect the parent-child relationship after divorce.

An easy way to understand the integrated nature of these reforms is through a hypothetical family. This family is composed of a working father, a stay-at-home mother, and a young son. The father often does not come home until late at night, and the father’s and mother’s constant fighting leads See FATHER’S WEBSITE, http://www.fatherswebsite.com/; KYŌDŌ SHINKEN UNDŌ NETWORK, http://kyodosinken.com/.

TAKAO TANASE, RIKONGO NO KYŌDŌ YŌIKU NARABI NI OYAKO KŌRYŪ WO SOKUSHINSURU

HŌRITSU (DAI 3A AN) (2010).

COMMITTEE ON JUDICIAL AFFAIRS, 174TH DIET, MINUTES, 12th Meeting (Mar. 9, 2010), 21st Meeting (April 16, 2010), available at http://www.shugiin.go.jp/index.nsf/html/index_kaigiroku.htm.

Id.

COMMITTEE ON JUDICIAL AFFAIRS, 174TH DIET, MINUTES, 12th Meeting (Mar. 9, 2010), available at http://www.shugiin.go.jp/index.nsf/html/index_kaigiroku.htm.

Id.

JUNE 2011 DIVORCE AND THE WELFARE OF THE CHILD IN JAPAN 605

to a straining of their relationship and eventually divorce. Under the current law, the statistics show a high likelihood that the mother would get sole custody over their son, and that the father would only be able to visit his child about one day per month.110 If the visitation system alone was reformed, as Justice Minister Chiba suggested, the father would probably lose all parental rights and responsibilities, and the son would lose the security and stability of retaining both parents under the law. In addition, the parents would still not be required to make any sort of agreement on how they will continue to care for their child following divorce, and a judge would never have an opportunity to verify that their agreement conforms to the standard of reasonable visitation.

If the custody system alone was reformed, the father would not have any guaranteed right to joint custody or visitation. There is still a chance that the father could lose contact with his son if the mother is strongly opposed to a joint custody arrangement. Also, without reform of kyōgi rikon, a judge would never have the opportunity to verify whether the rights of both parents and their son are all sufficiently protected through an enforceable parenting plan.

If the kyōgi rikon system alone was reformed, the courts would likely be hesitant to award the father anything more than one day of visitation every month, and could even deny visitation if the mother was firmly opposed. This option also fails to provide a way for the father and mother to share custody, even if the parents desire to share custody over their son.

This might even drive a larger wedge between the father and mother if they both try to claim custody over their son.

The Japanese Diet111 has shown an interest in starting the process of reform, but current proposals look to be too limited in scope. In October 28, 2010, the House of Representatives announced it had reached a nonpartisan agreement to draft legislation protecting the visitation rights of the noncustodial parent.112 However, this legislation has yet to be drafted, much less passed into law, and the announcement only talked about visitation reform without addressing joint custody and kyōgi rikon issues. While this 2009 COURT STATISTICS, supra note 24.

The Diet is the legislative branch of the Japanese government, and is composed of the lower House of Representatives and the upper House of Councilors. NIHONKOKU KENPŌ [KENPŌ] [CONSTITUTION], arts. 41-42 (Japan).

Chotōha Giinga Shinhō Jyunbi—Rikonshita Chichioyani mo Kodomo Awasete [Bipartisan Lawmakers Preparing Legislation to Allow Divorced Fathers to Visit Their Children], THE SANKEI SHINBUN (Oct. 29, 2010), http://sankei.jp.msn.com/politics/situation/101029/stt1010290130000-n1.htm (last visited Jan. 4, 2011).

606 PACIFIC RIM LAW & POLICY JOURNAL VOL. 20 NO. 3 is certainly a step in the right direction, effective reform will need to be comprehensive.

–  –  –

This comment has made three proposals to reform the Japanese family law system relating to visitation, custody, and the kyōgi rikon divorce system. These three reforms rely on each other to form a comprehensive whole. Japanese lawmakers have already taken the first few steps down this path, but change will be long and difficult. Any significant change will need to overcome tradition and decades of legislative inaction. Social attitudes will need to evolve with the text of the law itself, and this will require tailoring solutions to specific Japanese social considerations.

Successful reform will not be measured by the text of any new law but rather in that law’s ability to protect the relationship between parents and children.113 The proposals in this comment are not the only way forward, and it is important to consider all options when creating new standards for divorce, custody, and visitation. However, research establishes the fundamental importance of the parent-child bond,114 and any new law must take all reasonable measures to protect this relationship with both parents.

Reform must be based on this fundamental premise if it is to spare the next generation of children from inadequate protections and allow them to receive stable and continuous love and care from both of their parents.

–  –  –



Pages:     | 1 |   ...   | 2 | 3 ||


Similar works:

«Europe’s tax deals for diesel October 2015 a study by Analysis by Transport & Environment, with data support from CE Delft Published by Transport & Environment For more information, contact: Carlos Calvo Ambel Policy Analyst Transport & Environment Carlos.calvoambel@transportenvironment.org Tel: +32(0)2 851 02 13 a study by Executive summary & policy recommendations Low oil prices – ideal time to act At the time of writing, the oil price was some 70% below its 2008 peak and some 60% below...»

«Abstract SUMMARY 20th Section Fall Meeting October 10-13, 2012 Austin, TX THURSDAY, OCTOBER 10, 2012 8:30 a.m. – 10:00 a.m.PLENARY SESSION: LEGAL GUIDANCE FOR U.S. ENERGY PROVIDERS IN THE ERA OF SHIFTING NATIONAL ENERGY POLICY Legal Guidance for U.S. Energy Providers in the Era of Shifting National Energy Policy: GHG and Other Significant Regulatory Challenges Kimberly S. Bowers, Executive Vice President and General Counsel, Valero Energy Corporation, San Antonio, TX Marcus V. Brown, Senior...»

«IFPRI Discussion Paper 00803 October 2008 Biofuels, Poverty, and Growth A Computable General Equilibrium Analysis of Mozambique Channing Arndt Rui Benfica Finn Tarp James Thurlow Rafael Uaiene Development Strategy and Governance Division INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE The International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) was established in 1975. IFPRI is one of 15 agricultural research centers that receive principal funding from governments, private foundations, and...»

«South Asian Studies A Research Journal of South Asian Studies Vol. 28, No. 1, January – June 2013, pp.151-164 Dogmas and Doctrines of the Roshnites and the Dispute of Pantheism Zahid Shah COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Abbottabad ABSTRACT The Roshnites (Illuminati) also called “Rokhanian” in Pashto, a sixteenth century religiopolitical movement in the Pashtun dominated regions of Pakistan and Afghanistan, effected social mobilization on an unprecedented scale. The movement...»

«Overview of North Carolina Spiny Dogfish Regulations and Commercial Landings North Carolina Division of Marine Fisheries Information Paper North Carolina Department of Environment and Natural Resources Division of Marine Fisheries Morehead City, NC 28557 March 2008 Overview of North Carolina Spiny Dogfish Regulations and Commercial Landings1 Prior to 2000 there were no regulatory measures in place to control harvest of spiny dogfish along the east coast of the United States. In April 1998 the...»

«From fashion to ethical fashion: How political consumerist movements change markets Philip Balsiger University of Lausanne Paper to be presented at the ECPR General Conference, Reykjavik, August 24-27 2011 Section: Contentious Politics in Times of Crisis Panel: A New Rising Star? Political Consumerism and New Sustainable Community Movements in a Comparative Perspective DRAFT. PLEASE DO NOT QUOTE WITHOUT PERMISSION Abstract This is a comparative study of the transformations of the market for...»

«Calculating Practices Steven MacLennan Edinburgh Working Papers in Sociology No. 36 February 2009 Copyright: Steven MacLennan, 2009 ISBN: 1-900522-58-6 Edinburgh Working Papers in Sociology are published by the Sociology subject area, School of Social & Political Science, University of Edinburgh.They include: i. preliminary results of research in progress ii. contributions to conceptual or theoretical debate within sociology iii. contributions to public debate about social issues. A full list...»

«Communication: An Essential Aspect of Diplomacy Christer Jönsson & Martin Hall Department of Political Science, Lund University christer.jonsson@svet.lu.se martin.hall@svet.lu.se [Prepared for 43rd Annual ISA Convention, New Orleans, LA, March 23-27, 2002; panel WA23: Diplomatic Theory and Practice] Communication is to diplomacy as blood is to the human body. Whenever communication ceases, the body of international politics, the process of diplomacy, is dead, and the result is violent conflict...»

«Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenSSH Server Cryptographic Module version 4.0 FIPS 140-2 Non-Proprietary Security Policy Version 1.5 Last update: 2016-06-13 Prepared by: atsec information security corporation 9130 Jollyville Road, Suite 260 Austin, TX 78759 www.atsec.com ©2016 Red Hat Enterprise Linux / atsec information security corporation Page 1 of 21 This document can be reproduced and distributed only whole and intact, including this copyright notice. Red Hat Enterprise Linux OpenSSH Server...»

«Phi Beta Kappa Oration Theta Chapter of Pennsylvania May 15, 2009 Liberal Education and Liberal Politics Robert Friedrich, Chapter President A few minutes ago I read to you the words of Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes when he addressed the Phi Beta Kappa chapter at Brown University back in 1930. “The particular interest of Phi Beta Kappa is liberal education,” he said, and “It holds aloft the old banner of scholarship.” Gazing at that old banner today, what we see looks a little...»

«Página inicial: 147 Página final: 175 TIPO DE ARTÍCULO: de Investigación EL PAPEL DEL CONFLICTO ARMADO EN LA CONSTRUCCIÓN Y DIFERENCIACIÓN TERRITORIAL DE LA REGIÓN DE “EL CAGUÁN”, AMAZONÍA OCCIDENTAL COLOMBIANA1. THE ROLE OF THE ARMED CONFLICT IN THE CONSTRUCTION AND TERRITORIAL DIFFERENTIATION IN “THE CAGUAN” REGION, WESTERN COLOMBIAN AMAZON. Recibido: Junio 2013 Revisado: Octubre 2013 Aceptado: Diciembre 10 de 2013 Por: Teófilo Vásquez1. RESUMEN. En este artículo se...»

«Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council EDP Interagency Examination, Scheduling and Distribution Policy 1776 G Street, NW, Suite 850B  Washington, DC 20006  (202) 357-0177  Fax (202) 357-0191 Purpose This policy provides for joint examinations of data centers providing services to insured institutions supervised by more than one federal regulatory agency. It is expected to eliminate the need for separate examinations of data processors by more than one federal financial...»





 
<<  HOME   |    CONTACTS
2016 www.dis.xlibx.info - Thesis, dissertations, books

Materials of this site are available for review, all rights belong to their respective owners.
If you do not agree with the fact that your material is placed on this site, please, email us, we will within 1-2 business days delete him.